Skip to content

IMPORTANT UPDATE: Due to current fuel costs all orders will receive a 2.5% fuel surcharge at checkout. Thank you for understanding.

Welcome to Cincy Favorites!

SHOP
New Arrivals
Gift Guides
Subscribe & Save
Corporate & E-Gifting
Rewards

Need help ? Email UsCall UsAddress: 109 Illinois Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45215

Products

Products

Get exactly what you want in your package! Add-items are not to be purchased alone.

Graeter's Ice Cream

The BonBonerie Bakery

College Hill Cakery

Sunshine Caramel Company

Taste of Belgium

Filter

Product categories

20% OFF Cakes (9)

Add-On Items (58)

America 250th (21)

Best Sellers (108)

Busken Bakery (2)

Cincy Date Night Kits (12)

Cincy Farmers Market (17)

Cincy Gift Baskets (7)

Cincy Gift Collection (28)

Cincy Party Packs (8)

College Hill Cakery (4)

Combo Packs (13)

Dessert Guide (27)

Father's Day Gifts (28)

Frisch's (1)

Frisch's Tartar Sauce (1)

Gift Guides (26)

Gifts Under $99 (93)

Glier's Goetta (7)

Graeter's Ice Cream (4)

Grill Master Bundles (21)

Grippo's Chips (4)

Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse (5)

LaRosa's (12)

Mandatory Fees (1)

Memorial Day Favorites (20)

Montgomery Inn (25)

Mother's Day Collection (31)

National Dessert Day Sale (27)

New Arrivals (18)

Perishable Items (144)

Product Bundles (19)

Queen City Sausage (8)

Russo's Ravioli (5)

Sakura (1)

Servatii's Pastry Shop (5)

Skyline Chili (18)

Skyline Chili Week Sale (18)

St. Francis Apizza (3)

Subscribe & Save (20)

Summer Collection (141)

Sunshine Caramel Company (6)

Taste of Belgium (5)

Thanksgiving Essentials (31)

The BonBonerie Bakery (4)

The Enquirer's Top Picks (19)

The Masters Tournament Bundles (28)

Top Gifts (68)

Valentine's Day Favorites (42)

Villari Foods (9)

Virginia Bakery (2)

World Cup Bundles (28)

Brand

0 selected

Add-On (1)
Cincy Favorites (5)
College Hill Cakery (4)
Combo Packs (13)
Frisch's (1)
Glier's (12)
Graeter's (13)
Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse (5)
LaRosa's (19)
Montgomery Inn (34)
Queen City Sausage (17)
Russo's Ravioli (5)
Sakura (1)
Servatii's Pastry Shop (10)
Skyline Chili (24)
St. Francis Apizza (3)
Sunshine Caramel Company (7)
Taste of Belgium (6)
The BonBonerie Bakery (4)
Villari Foods (12)
Virginia Bakery (3)

Price

Price:

$

-

$

Availability

0 selected

In stock (199)
Out of stock (1)

Sort by

Chop Lover's Bundle (12 lbs avg.)

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Villari Foods Chop Lover's Bundle (12 lbs avg.)

Sale priceFrom $139.95

Chop Lover's Kit (7 lbs avg.)

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Villari Foods Chop Lover's Kit (7 lbs avg.)

Sale priceFrom $99.99

Cincinnati Hot Dogs (6 Packs)

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Queen City Sausage Cincinnati Hot Dogs (6 Packs)

Sale price$99.99

Cincinnati Recipe Chili Mix

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Skyline Chili Cincinnati Recipe Chili Mix

Sale priceFrom $39.99

Cincinnati Recipe Chili Mix (1-pack) (add-on item)

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Add-On Cincinnati Recipe Chili Mix (1-pack) (add-on item)

Sale price$5.99

Collection of Montgomery Inn food products including pulled pork, Skyline chili, and Graeter's on a blue background.

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Montgomery Inn Cincy College Survival Kit

Sale price$119.99

Cincy Favorites Gift Card

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Cincy Favorites Cincy Favorites Gift Card

Sale priceFrom $50.00

Collection of food items including a LaRosa's pizza, Montgomery Inn Pulled Pork, Skyline chili, Graeter's Ice Cream and other products on a red background

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: Combo Packs Cincy's Favorite Party Pack

Sale price$149.99

College Hill Cakery Gooey Butter Coffee Cake (2 or 4 Pack)

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: College Hill Cakery College Hill Cakery Gooey Butter Coffee Cake (2 or 4 Pack)

Sale priceFrom $89.99

College Hill Cakery Original Gooey Buttercake (2 or 4 Pack)

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: College Hill Cakery College Hill Cakery Original Gooey Buttercake (2 or 4 Pack)

Sale priceFrom $89.99

College Hill Cakery Pumpkin Gooey Buttercake (2 Pack)

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: College Hill Cakery College Hill Cakery Pumpkin Gooey Buttercake (2 Pack)

Sale price$89.99

College Hill Cakery Variety Pack

Add to Wishlist

Vendor: College Hill Cakery College Hill Cakery Variety Pack

Sale price$89.99

Previous
1
2
3
4
…
17
Next

SHOP

All Products
The Best Sellers
Gifts Under $99
Bakery & Desserts
Order Gift Card

ABOUT

Our Story
Rewards Programs
Gift Certificate

CUSTOMER LINKS

Contact Us
Shipping & Returns
Track Your Order
Privacy Policy
FAQs

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook
Instagram

© 2025 Cincy Favorites. All Rights Reserved. Site by The Media Captain.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.
Opens external website.
Opens external website in a new window.

Search our site

Need some inspiration?

Glier's Goetta stacked with branding on a black background

Add to Wishlist

Glier's Original Goetta (6 or 12 Pack)

Sale priceFrom $99.99

Six Graeter's ice cream tubs arranged in a cluster on a solid deep purple background. The flavors shown are Double Chocolate Chip, Strawberry, Madagascar Vanilla, Black Raspberry Chip, Butter Pecan, and Mint Chip.

Add to Wishlist

Graeter's Signature Selection Pints (6 or 12 Pack)

Sale priceFrom $99.99

Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse Seasoning (2 Pack)

Add to Wishlist

Jeff Ruby's Steakhouse Seasoning (2 Pack)

Sale price$59.99

Montgomery Inn Barbecue ribs on a cutting board with a bottle of barbecue sauce on a wooden surface

Add to Wishlist

Montgomery Inn Ribs and BBQ Sauce

Sale priceFrom $99.99

Wicker basket with cans of Skyline Chili, Oyster Crackers, and York Peppermint Patties on a purple background

Add to Wishlist

Skyline Craver Gift Set

Sale priceFrom $79.99

View all

Reset your password

Log in

Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.

Email*

Cancel

Email*

Password*

Forgot your password?

New customer? Create your account

Create account

First name

Last name

Email*

Password*

Already have an account? Login here

Ask a Question

Your Name (required)

Your Email (required)

Product

Message (required)