THE BEST CINCY DESSERTS

Indulge in the iconic desserts that Cincinnati locals have loved for generations. Our Cincy Desserts collection brings together the city’s most beloved sweet treats—crafted by legendary hometown bakeries and ice cream makers, and delivered straight to your door.

From rich, decadent pastries to unforgettable ice cream and bakery classics, every bite captures the authentic flavors and traditions that make Cincinnati desserts truly special. Whether you’re treating yourself, sending a gift, or finishing off a Cincy-style feast, these sweets are guaranteed to delight.

Discover the desserts that make Cincinnati famous—one delicious bite at a time.

Sort by

Slice of Servatii's pumpkin pie on a plate with a gold spoon against a black background
Add to Wishlist
Montgomery Inn Volcano Cakes and Greater's Ice Cream
Add to Wishlist
Slice of Servatii's apple pie on a decorative plate with a spoon on a black background
Add to Wishlist
Slice of Servatii's Cherry pie on a decorative plate with a spoon on a black background
Add to Wishlist
College Hill Cakery Gooey Butter Coffee Cake (2 or 4 Pack)
Add to Wishlist
A white chocolate bumbleberry cake with red fruit topping is displayed on a glass pedestal stand, with a single slice placed on a white plate in front. The cake is decorated with piped white frosting and red-and-green candy accents, set on a patterned gray tablecloth.
Add to Wishlist
Three packages of Sunshine Caramel candy on a pink surface with a blue background
Add to Wishlist
Sunshine Caramel Glass of whiskey with a caramel square and butter on a blue background
Add to Wishlist
Servatii's Pumpkin pie slice with two containers of vanilla bean ice cream on a dark background
Add to Wishlist
College Hill Cakery Pumpkin Gooey Buttercake (2 Pack)
Add to Wishlist
Sunshine Caramel candy with a glass of coffee and scattered coffee beans on a yellow background
Add to Wishlist
Sunshine Caramel Vanilla extract bottle, vanilla beans, and a piece of caramel on a blue background
Add to Wishlist
Sunshine Caramel Half-cut orange and a piece of caramel on a pink background
Add to Wishlist

SHOP CINCY FAVS

THE BEST SELLERS

SHOP

BAKERY & DESSERTS

SHOP

GIFTS UNDER $99

SHOP