Vanilla Graeter's ice cream pint with heart-shaped cookies on a wooden board

CINCY VALENTINE'S DAY GIFT GUIDE

Set the mood this Valentine’s Day with Cincy Favorites. From cozy date night kits to decadent desserts, our Valentine’s Day Gift Guide features iconic Cincinnati food brands—delivered nationwide.

Vanilla Graeter's ice cream pint with heart-shaped cookies on a wooden board
Graeter's Ice Cream
The BonBonerie Bakery
College Hill Cakery
Sunshine Caramel Company
Taste of Belgium
Filter

Sort by
College Hill Cakery Variety Pack
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: College Hill CakeryCollege Hill Cakery Variety Pack
Sale price$89.99
Virginia Bakery Schnecken and Graeter's Ice Cream
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Virginia BakeryVirginia Bakery Schnecken and Graeter's Ice Cream
Sale price$59.99
Graeter's Chocolate Chip (6 or 12 Pints)
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Graeter'sGraeter's Chocolate Chip (6 or 12 Pints)
Sale priceFrom $99.99
Montgomery Inn Date Night Kit
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Montgomery InnMontgomery Inn Date Night Kit
Sale price$129.99
Servatii's Carrot cake with decorative carrots and green candies on a black background
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Servatii's Pastry ShopSERVATii's Carrot Cake
Sale price$59.99
College Hill Cakery Original Gooey Buttercake (2 or 4 Pack)
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: College Hill CakeryCollege Hill Cakery Original Gooey Buttercake (2 or 4 Pack)
Sale priceFrom $89.99
A Bonbonerie Opera Cream Cake and a Bonbonerie Carrot cake on a table with a box labeled 'BonBonerie' in the background.
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: The BonBonerie BakeryBonbonerie Opera Cream & Carrot Cake
Sale price$124.99
Taste of Belgium Waffles and Graeters Ice Cream
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Taste of BelgiumTaste of Belgium Waffles and Graeters Ice Cream
Sale price$139.99
LaRosa's Pepperoni pizza with two chocolate-glazed volcano cakes and a container of ice cream on a wooden surface.
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: LaRosa'sLaRosa's Date Night Kit
Sale price$99.99
Fill the Pantry
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Combo PacksFill the Pantry
Sale priceFrom $75.99
Slice of Servatii's pumpkin pie on a plate with a gold spoon against a black background
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Servatii's Pastry ShopSERVATii's Pumpkin Pies (2 Pack)
Sale price$69.99
Montgomery Inn Volcano Cakes and Greater's Ice Cream
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Montgomery InnMontgomery Inn Volcano Cakes and Greater's Ice Cream
Sale price$89.99
Sunshine Caramel Caramel candy with a spoonful of caramel and salt on a blue background
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Sunshine Caramel CompanySunshine Caramel Sea Salt Caramels (2 or 4 Pack)
Sale priceFrom $29.99
Skyline Chili Date Night Kit
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Skyline ChiliSkyline Chili Date Night Kit
Sale price$119.99
Slice of Servatii's Cherry pie on a decorative plate with a spoon on a black background
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: Servatii's Pastry ShopSERVATii's Cherry Pies (2 Pack)
Sale price$69.99
College Hill Cakery Gooey Butter Coffee Cake (2 or 4 Pack)
Add to Wishlist
Vendor: College Hill CakeryCollege Hill Cakery Gooey Butter Coffee Cake (2 or 4 Pack)
Sale priceFrom $89.99

SHOP CINCY FAVS

THE BEST SELLERS

SHOP

BAKERY & DESSERTS

SHOP

GIFTS UNDER $99

SHOP